Health

It’s better for your health to be alone than trapped in an unhappy relationship 

  • Study looked at young people from two-parent families in America
  • Found poor relationships negatively affected physical and mental health
  • Scientists say quality of a relationship is what is important not act itself

Kate Pickles For Mailonline

12

View
comments

It’s been the punchline of many a best man’s speech over the years but now it’s official.

Experts say it is better to be single than be involved in a poor-quality relationship.

A study found that being trapped in an unhappy partnership is so damaging to a person’s health, they would be better off alone.

What’s more, it gets worse the longer you are together, the researchers concluded.

Happily, they found that the reverse is also true – that being in a high-quality relationship benefits your physical and mental health.

Researchers found that being in a high quality relationship -or happy and single - are both good for physical and mental health. Prince Harry has spoken about wanting to find love and start a family like his brother William has with Kate (pictured)

Researchers found that being in a high quality relationship -or happy and single – are both good for physical and mental health. Prince Harry has spoken about wanting to find love and start a family like his brother William has with Kate (pictured)

The research team from the University of Buffalo in New York studied the relationships of young people from rural Iowa. 

The subjects were from two-parent, married families, but the majority were not married.

With growing numbers of people now choosing to put off marriage in favour of more casual relationships, the scientists wanted to look at the impact this had on their health.

They asked the participants about the quality of their relationships, questioning how committed they were, how they dealt with criticism, and the support and affection they gave and received.

The team also asked how the partners behaved outside of the relationship – including whether they engage in risky behaviour.

Ashley Barr, assistant professor in the university’s department of sociology, said the research showed that the longer people are in high-quality relationships – or, alternatively, the faster they got out of low-quality partnerships – the better their health.

‘Health benefits begin to accrue relatively quickly with high-quality relationships and supportive contexts,’ she said.

Low-quality relationships, especially those which last for a long time, can have a detrimental effect on a person's physical and mental health

Low-quality relationships, especially those which last for a long time, can have a detrimental effect on a person’s physical and mental health

‘And then we see detrimental effects from low-quality relationships – particularly, those low-quality relationships that last a long time.’

Professor Barr added: ‘The findings suggest that it’s better for health to be single than to be in a low-quality relationship.

‘It’s not being in a relationship that matters; it’s being in a long-term, high-quality relationship that’s beneficial.

‘Low-quality relationships are detrimental to health. The findings suggest that it’s better for health to be single than to be in a low-quality relationship.’

Dr Barr said relationships tended to change the older people became.

‘It’s rare today for young adults to enter a romantic relationship and stay in that relationship without ever changing partners or relationship characteristics.

‘We now have two studies that found similar patterns and similar implications for those changes.’

The study was published in the Journal of Family Psychology.

 

Comments (12)

Share what you think

The comments below have not been moderated.

The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline.

Find out now