Unsafe medical devices ‘given OK by Brussels’ putting Patients at risk
- European Commission watchdog gave green light to equipment
- Researchers claim there is a ‘lack of transparancy’ in the system
- Unsafe breast implants also three times more likely to be approved by EU
Sophie Borland Health Editor For The Daily Mail
31
View
comments
Patients are being harmed because the EU regulator is giving its approval to faulty medical equipment
Patients are being harmed because the EU regulator is giving its approval to faulty medical equipment and implants used in common operations, researchers warn.
They found the European Commission watchdog had given the green light to blood vessel stents which caused strokes, devices to reduce back pain that led to fits and malfunctioning defibrillators.
They also discovered that unsafe breast implants were three times more likely to be approved by the EU than its counterpart in the US.
Researchers from Harvard University in the US and King’s College London say there is an ‘absolute lack of transparency’ in the EU’s system which is denying doctors and patients vital information about how devices were approved and the risks they carry.
They blame the shortcomings for creating the recent PIP silicone breast implant scandal, as well as the use of faulty metal-on-metal hips.
The French-made implants were never approved in the US but were given to 47,000 British women after EU approval in the 1990s.
It was later discovered they had double the rupture rate and used industrial silicone.
The EU also gave the green light to metal-on-metal hip implants, given to up to 50,000 patients in Britain, which leach chemicals into the blood.
Dr Thomas Hwang, an expert in technology at Harvard University, said patients were being put at risk by a ‘absolute vacuum of information’ within the EU system.
-
Glass eyes, clunky metal arms and oxygen pumps for poisoned…
Man who went to the doctors complaining about his ‘beer…
‘We are Europe!’ Picture from London hospital shows surgical…
Are YOU terrified of childbirth? More women than ever are -…
He said: ‘If my surgeon was going to implant a device, I would absolutely want to know all the evidence.
‘The point of this paper was to raise concerns about the absolute lack of transparency in the EU. There isn’t any information on how a device works, evidence of benefits and also the risks.
‘Patients can’t really give informed consent as they don’t know all the risks and benefits.’
Approved medical devices in the EU are given a Conformité Européenne (CE) kitemark.
The researches blame these shortcomings for creating the recent PIP silicone breast implant scandal, as well as the use of faulty metal-on-metal hips
But officials do not demand to see any evidence from clinical trials carried out by manufacturers – they just ask for documents to show devices are ‘generally safe’ and work ‘as intended’.
The US system, regulated by the Food and Drug Administration, demands data from trials. Although it takes longer and devices are not available for use as quickly compared to the EU, they tend to be safer.
In Britain, the Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulator Agency regulates devices but can only recall them once safety concerns have been raised.
It does not carry out prior checks before they are used in hospital.
Peter Walsh, of patient safety charity Action Against Medical Accidents, said: ‘Medical devices are known to cause over 100 deaths a year and thousands of serious injuries.
‘Regulation and approval processes need to be improved.’
Share or comment on this article
-
Video appears to show gunman being shot then bomb detonated
-
CCTV appears to show moment bomb goes off at Istanbul…
-
Shocking video of mistress beaten in street by angry wife
-
Black teen tasered by Wisconsin police at shopping mall
-
New ISIS video shows footage of San Fran’s Golden Gate…
-
GRAPHIC Brooklyn woman fights attacker who tried to rape her
-
People cower on floor at Istanbul airport after bomb blasts
-
‘Drunk’ party girl leaves dead body in car after hit and run
-
Bully gets knocked out and humiliated by smaller kid
-
See the wall Mark Zuckerberg is building at his Hawaii…
-
Drone films couple having sex on top of Russian monastery
-
Former anchors indicted after baby tests positive for…
-
‘There was blood and body parts everywhere’: Terrifying…
-
Mark Zuckerberg causes outrage after he starts building a…
-
Married TV reporters in Arizona arrested and charged after…
-
DUI suspect ‘kept driving for a MILE with a dead pedestrian…
-
What are military UN trucks doing in Virginia? Bemused…
-
PIERS MORGAN: How can Kim Kardashian call herself a feminist…
-
Father-of-two, 41, could become second Texan to lose a leg…
-
911 tapes reveal how mom who gunned down both her daughters…
-
Has Britain avoided a ‘European superstate’? France and…
-
EXCLUSIVE: Just five weeks until the Olympics and this is…
-
Contractor who was charged in Christmas Day fire at…
-
‘Don’t do this. They’re our kids!’ Texas father watched in…
Comments (31)
Share what you think
-
Newest -
Oldest -
Best rated -
Worst rated
The comments below have not been moderated.
The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline.
Find out now