HMN 2025: How CDC pulls vaccine slide after knowledgeable cites study would not exist

A presentation scheduled for a U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) vaccine assembly at the moment claimed {that a} vaccine preservative may trigger long-term mind results—however the study it cited would not seem to exist.

The slide, posted on-line Tuesday, cited a 2008 paper titled “Low-level neonatal thimerosal publicity: Long-term penalties within the mind,” and was stated to have been revealed within the journal Neurotoxicology.

The slide stated the analysis confirmed that thimerosal, a vaccine preservative, precipitated lasting mind adjustments in rats, CNN reported.

But the scientist named on the slide, Robert Berman of the University of California-Davis, says he by no means wrote such a paper.

“I haven’t got a publication in Neurotoxicology by that title,” Berman advised CNN. “The reference within the slide set, so far as I do know—no less than with me as a co-author—doesn’t exist.”

Berman did publish a similar-sounding study in 2008, nevertheless it was in Toxicological Sciences, concerned mice—not rats—and got here to a dramatically completely different conclusion, CNN stated.

“My study was revealed in Toxicological Sciences and didn’t discover proof of thimerosal publicity at vaccine ranges in mouse behaviors that we thought had been related to autism,” Berman stated.

He added that he was “involved and displeased” that his analysis was cited incorrectly.

The CDC shortly eliminated the unique presentation and changed it with a brand new model that does not embody the quotation.

The error was first seen by Dr. David Boulware, an infectious illness knowledgeable on the University of Minnesota, who advised CNN that he tried to seek out the paper however could not.

The presentation was scheduled to be given by Lyn Redwood, a registered nurse and former chief of Children’s Health Defense, an anti-vaccine group.

It lists U.S. Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. as a founder.

Redwood is scheduled to current on the CDC’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices assembly at the moment. Neither she nor HHS instantly responded to CNN’s request for remark.

Thimerosal has lengthy been a spotlight of false claims linking vaccines to autism. But research have proven no such hyperlink. In truth, thimerosal was taken out of most vaccines about 25 years in the past, and analysis has not discovered it to trigger any hurt in relation to vaccines.

Redwood has stated in a video on Children’s Health Defense’s web site that she believes thimerosal led to her son’s autism.

The thimerosal subject was added to the vaccine advisers’ agenda on the final minute, elevating considerations that the panel may give consideration to debunked claims.

The controversy comes after Kennedy removed all 17 members of the vaccine panel, saying that they had conflicts of curiosity. He changed them with eight new members, lots of whom are vaccine skeptics.

Many public well being leaders say this transfer is troubling. U.S. Sen. Bill Cassidy of Louisiana, a health care provider and Republican who chairs the Senate Health Committee, stated the assembly must be delayed till the panel has extra balanced illustration, CNN reported.

This is not the primary time Kennedy’s workforce has been linked to incorrect citations. A latest report from the Trump-era “Make America Healthy Again” initiative additionally included references to research that could not be verified.

When requested about it throughout a congressional listening to, Kennedy stated the claims within the report had been correct and that the quotation errors “had been corrected inside 24 hours.”

© 2025 .