Surgical technique for the treatment of renal cell carcinoma with inferior vena cava tumor thrombus: tips, tricks and oncological results

Patient is placed in supine with extension of the lumbar lordosis in order to get
a correct access to both subdiaphragmatic spaces. To gain optimal surgical exposure,
we perform a bilateral subcostal incision (chevron) 3–4 cm below the costal margin,
which sometimes it is extended in the midline vertically up to xiphoid process (triradiate
incision). Rochard retractor is placed (Fig. 3), elevating costal margins and splaying them laterally. With this exposure liver
mobilization or en bloc mobilization of the left upper quadrant abdominal structures
(stomach, pancreas and spleen) will be easier.

Fig. 3. Chevron incision with Rochard retractor, enabling correct exposure of upper abdominal
quadrants

Early ligation of renal artery

Kidney mobilization begins laterally and posteriorly, after opening parietal peritoneum,
and mobilizing medially the kidney tumor until reaching the renal artery outside Zuckerkandl
fascia. Once there, artery is ligated and divided (Fig. 4). The main advantage of this approach is that it encounters fewer collateral vessels
than the classic anterior approach, and it allows an early collapse of collaterals
circulation, reducing the bleeding and facilitating further dissection (Ciancio et
al. 2003]). To our knowledge, it is a good alternative to preoperative renal artery embolization
and technically feasible.

Fig. 4. Early access and ligation of the renal artery during a left radical nephrectomy and
IVC thrombectomy. The artery is dissected outside Zuckerkandl’s fascia and prior to
perform the kidney’s anterior surface dissection

Level I tumor thrombus

Thrombus inside renal vein or reaching ostium in IVC can be resected safely with minimal
dissection of IVC. After early ligation of renal artery, careful dissection of IVC
2 cm above and below the renal vein should be done. At this point, with a milking
maneuver, thrombus can be pulled back to the renal vein and then a clamp is placed
in the ostium. If circumstances do not allow bringing back the tumor into the renal
vein, cavotomy and thrombectomy will be necessary. After clamping contralateral renal
vein and the IVC above and below the thrombus, procedure can be done safely. It is
important to note that every attempt to clamp the IVC should be preceded by a complete
circumferential dissection and vascular control, in order to avoid massive blood loss.
Abbasi reported that almost 40 % of cadaveric dissections presented a posterior lumbar
vein (80 % men) draining in IVC above renal vein, contradicting classical anatomic
texts assertion, and this unexpected vein was an unrecognized source of massive bleeding
during surgery (Abbasi et al. 2012]). Once the kidney is removed with the thrombus, closure of cavotomy is done with
4-0 Prolene running suture.

Level II tumor thrombus

This level requires a more extensive vascular dissection, in order to get a correct
exposure of infrahepatic and retrohepatic IVC. After early ligation of renal artery,
liver’s posterior surface mobilization will be needed, exposing anterior and lateral
surface of IVC. During this step, minor hepatic veins will be dissected, ligated and
divided. Once again, total vascular control and circumferential IVC dissection are
mandatory. Vascular clamps are placed in contralateral renal vein, below and above
the thrombus, and then cavotomy and thrombectomy are performed safely. Nephrectomy
is completed and closure of cavotomy is done with 4-0 Prolene running suture.

Level III tumor thrombus

Given the close relation of the thrombus with the major hepatic veins and the retrohepatic
IVC segment, a complete liver mobilization and IVC exposure is mandatory. Most of
the surgical steps in this approach are derived from liver transplantation techniques.
Mobilization begins with ligamentun teres, which is divided. After dividing falciform ligament, the incision is carried down
to right superior coronary and triangular ligaments. Incision will continue with visceral
peritoneum lateral to hepatic hilium, right inferior coronary ligament and hepatorenal
ligaments. Thus, liver is softly rolled to the left abdomen, as previously described
(Ciancio et al. 2011]). Surgical control of the hepatic hilium is performed, allowing to use Pringle maneuver
when needed (temporarily clamping portal vein and hepatic artery, mandatory if the
thrombus reaches above hepatic veins). Then, “piggy-back” maneuver is performed (Fig. 5), as described for liver transplantation (Tzakis et al. 1989]). It preserves IVC of the recipient, mobilizing the liver off the big vessel. To
gain this total mobilization of the liver, minor hepatic veins draining on the IVC
anterior surface are ligated and divided. In this fashion, the infrahepatic, retrohepatic
and suprahepatic portions of the IVC are completely exposed, so the liver remains
attached only by the hilium and the suprahepatic veins (Fig. 6). Finally, posterior surface of the IVC is completely dissected, in order to obtain
the total circumferential dissection of the IVC.

Fig. 5. Piggy-back maneuver. Liver mobilization off the IVC, remaining attached by suprahepatic
veins in their confluent with suprahepatic IVC

Fig. 6. Complete liver mobilization and circumferential IVC dissection, gaining total vascular
control. Minor hepatic veins draining from right and caudate hepatic lob are ligated

As described for level I, but for some thrombus level IIIb/IIIc, a manual milking
maneuver pulling the thrombus below the suprahepatic veins can be done, and the putting
the clamp below them. This step should be assisted by TEE control, assessing about
the level of the clamp and the potential dislodging of the thrombus and its subsequent
pulmonary embolism. This milking maneuver has two main advantages: it avoids hepatic
ischemia and it preserves liver drainage into the IVC through the suprahepatic veins
(with an acceptable venous return). This technique is often feasible, especially when
early ligation of renal artery was performed, because it reduces blood supply to the
tumor thrombus. For level IIId thrombus, and for those cases when milking maneuver
is not feasible, dissection continues until the supradiaphragmatic and intrapericardial
IVC, which is dissected circumferentially.

Once with IVC dissected, thrombectomy is performed previous correct sequential vascular
clamping: Pringle maneuver, IVC below the thrombus, contralateral renal vein, right
adrenal vein if needed, and IVC above the thrombus (below suprahepatic veins if milking
maneuver was successful or around supradiaphragmatic IVC if not). Cavotomy starts
through affected renal vein and is extended proximally as much as needed. Tumor thrombus
is removed completely, including adherent thrombus to IVC wall with sharp dissection.
Major hepatic veins and IVC wall can be directly visualized; it allows complete removing
of thrombus in their ostia. IVC closure is done with 2 Prolene 4-0 running sutures.

As previously commented, cases requiring hepatic ischemia and IVC clamping above hepatic
veins have surgical disadvantages, due to intraoperative venous return decrease and
to postoperative hepatic dysfunction. Thus, the less time the ischemia is established,
the less risk of perioperative complications. That is the reason why we routinely
recommend replacing clamps after thrombectomy. Once the thrombus is removed, a vascular
clamp is positioned immediately above the proximal segment of the cavotomy, so the
suprahepatic clamp and hepatic hilium clamp can be safely removed and then hepatic
circulation reestablished.

Level IV tumor thrombus

Early surgical approach of level IV thrombus relied on cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB).
It can produce platelet dysfunction and coagulopathy (Novick et al. 1990]), with the consequent extensive bleeding, and it is not exempt of complications arising
mainly from hypothermia. In our experience, CPB may be required in patients with a
large and fixed atrial thrombus. In these cases, collaboration with cardiothoracic
surgeons is necessary to remove all the thrombus from the right heart. However, patients
presenting with a little and not adherent atrial thrombus may be resectable through
a complete abdominal approach and would benefit from the use of liver transplantation
techniques described previously. After opening the central tendon of the diaphragm,
supradiaphragmatic and intrapericardial IVC is identified and dissected until it can
be correctly encircled (Fig. 7). Once here, confluence of IVC in the right atrium can be gently pulled to the abdomen,
bellow the diaphragm. Clamps positioning, cavotomy, thrombectomy and IVC reconstruction
should be done in conventional fashion (Fig. 8).

Fig. 7. Supradiaphragmatic and intrapericardial IVC dissection, which will be necessary for
level IIId and IV thrombus

Fig. 8. cavotomy and complete thrombectomy. Closure of the IVC is done with 4-0 non-absorbable
running suture

Need for IVC resection

Oncological success in RCC treatment will depend on the complete tumor removal. Sometimes
there is no only tumor thrombus, but the IVC wall is infiltrated and has to be removed.
It is quite difficult, but not impossible, to determine whether the IVC wall is invaded
or not. The assessment of some radiographic features was associated with a significantly
increased risk of IVC resection (Psutka et al. 2014]). Although useful for a good preoperative planning, only surgical exploration has
real value.

Resection of the IVC may not be necessary in most of the cases. Furthermore, complete
“piggyback” liver mobilization facilitates complete thrombectomy of large thrombus,
avoiding IVC resection. When IVC is affected by the tumor, the evaluation of collateral
vessels is useful to decide what to do. If complete occlusion of IVC is present with
chronic obstruction, an adequate blood flow through collaterals is presumed, creating
a natural veno-venous bypass. En bloc resection of the IVC can be performed safely
with low postoperative morbidity (Ciancio and Soloway 2005]; Kearney et al. 1981]). However, if collateral circulation is not present, resection of IVC should be avoided.
In this setting, IVC reconstruction can be done with prosthesis, usually a PTFE graft
(Fig. 9). Its main risk is thrombosis or infection (Caldarelli et al. 2002]). Other options are autologous vein grafts or pericardium (Marshall and Reitz 1985]).

Fig. 9. placement of a PTFE prosthesis after IVC resection, with end-to-side anastomosis to
left renal vein