healthmedicinet

Great progress has recently been made in the application of bioactive molecules isolated
from marine organisms such as sponges, jellyfish, sea-anemones, shellfish (Blue-Biotechnology)
representing an important resource useful to the health, food and processing or preservation
industries 1]-3]. The peculiarities of these molecules are stability, activity at low-temperature
and specificity of action. For these reasons new molecules from the body of invertebrate
marine organisms (Anthozoa) 4] were extracted and applied for biocleaning or controlling microbial growth on heritage
objects.

The earliest biocleaning attempts date back to 1970, initially performed to remove
animal glue layers from paper, canvas and polychrome artefacts, and later to hydrolyze
glue paste or protein/oily binder 5],6]. Another available alternative to enzymatic cleaning (stones) is the use of sulphate-reducing
bacteria (Desulfovibrio spp.), nitrate-reducing bacteria (Pseudomonas stutzeri) and others 7]-9]. Combining the metabolic activity of viable Pseudomonas stutzeri with enzymatic action (Protease) protein layers were removed from the surface of
frescoes 10].

In this study, Bioactive Molecules (BMs) with Proteolytic (BMPs) or Antimicrobial
(BMAs) activity were utilized for the biocleaning of casein layers, or to control
the microbial growth on glue paste-canvas substrates. BMs were extracted from the
body of marine organisms by homogenization (Ultra-Turrax-5 minutes in ice) in TBS
(150 mM NaCl/10 mM Tris–HCl pH 7.4) buffer, centrifuged (20’-21,000 g-4°C) and the
supernatant recovered. Proteins were analyzed by SDS–polyacrylamide gels, using 5%
(w/v) stacking ?15% (w/v) separating gel. After running (190 V-45 minutes) the gel
was stained in Coomassie solution (2 gr C-Brillant-Blue/500 ml methanol/100 ml acetic
acid/400 ml d-water) and de-stained (10% acetic acid/40% methanol/50% d-water). Protein
content was estimated by the Bradford method (standard?=?Bovine Serium Albumine) 11].

The BMPs showed a high gelatinolytic activity that disappears after adding 1.10-Phenanthroline
(metalloproteinase-inhibitor), suggesting that it is a metalloproteinase 12]. Casein layers were stratified on specimens surfaces in order to mimic the removal
of overflowing, disfiguring or simply an altered repainting, frequently performed
during the lifetime of the painting.

Cleaning tests were carried out on a 2 cm² casein layer on oil painting specimens laid on linen canvas: i) a preparatory ground (CaCO3/ linseed oil/ochre pigment); ii) a first paint layer (linseed oil/dark green pigment); iii) a second paint layer (casein medium binder/yellow ochre), on which the enzymes act.
The first green (for 2,000 hours) and the second casein (for 2,220 hours) layers were
artificially aged (UV-A 300–400 nm; T?=?22?±?5°C; RH?=?60-65%).

The casein layer was removed by BMP solution in 10 mM Tris–HCl pH 7.5 (without any
marine salt addition) or by Commercial Protease, as powder dissolved in 10 mM Tris–HCl
pH 7.5; both gelled in 5% Klucel, (Idrossi-propilcellulose) and stratified on the
specimen surface by plastic tips of volume variable pipettes. Gelling agents (Pluronic
F108 25-30%, Vanzan NFC 2-3%, Klucel-G 4-5%), were tested at different concentrations
in order to identify an adequate enzyme support (viscosity, water release), guarantying
stable reaction conditions and facilitating the cleaning procedure. The Yellow casein
layer was selectively removed after 10 min of application, by both BMP or commercial
protease solutions (Figure 1) without any undesired effects, as specifically assessed for BMP by portable spectrophotometer
Konica-Minolta-CM-2600d (sensitivity-ranging 360–740 nm, acquisition-pitch 10 nm).
Colorimetric measurements (Table 1) were performed on the green layer: before (1) and after being covered by the yellow
casein layer (2); finally, after removing the yellow casein layer by BMP (3). On the
green layer, BMP cleaning revealed no undesired effects as reported in Table 1: ?E (1–3) value, after removal of the yellow casein layer (2) was 0.96; a value well
below ?E 1.5 perceptible to the human eye 13]. Interestingly, the BMP enzyme was used at a significantly lower concentration (1 mg/ml)
1:10 with respect to the commercial one, and applied at room temperature (19-26°C)
while for commercial protease, heating at 37°C was needed. A negative control test
was conducted, applying the gelled solution (pH 7.5) free from the addition of any
enzyme, for each experiment.

Figure 1. Cleaning tests on painted canvas specimens (artificially aged) by BM Protease (B, C) or by commercial Protease (E, F), both supported by 5% Klucel gel. Enzymatic Cleaning: BMP applied for 5 min (B) and 10 min (C); Commercial Protease applied for 5 min (E) and 10 min (F). Control reactions: 5% Klucel gel applied for 10 min (A, D).

Table 1. Colour values, were calculated through the CIE 1976 L*, a*, b* (CIELAB) coordinate

In order to control and/or inhibit microbial colonization, other BMAs were tested
as potential “biocide molecules”. It is well known that a wide range of fungi and
bacteria are capable of growing on oil painting adhesive and canvases, and some have
been observed after the relining of degraded canvases 14]. In our laboratory, fungi and bacteria that are able to colonize glue paste – canvas
specimens were preliminarily isolated and characterized by microscopy and molecular
techniques 15]-17]. Particularly, Aspergillus sp. and Penicillium sp. conidiophores-conidia structures were observed (Figure 2A) under Scanning Electron (Leica Cambridge- Leo 420) after coated with gold particles
and Optical Microscopy (Leica DMIL) after Lugol staining (Figure 2B). Fungi were identified by in vitro amplification of rRNA-Internal Transcribed Sequences (Figure 2C, lanes A and P) as well as for bacterial colonies (Figure 2C, lanes B, M).

Figure 2. Bacteria and fungi identification by integrated approach. Microscopy analysis: A) SEM micrograph Penicillium; B) Optical observation of Lugol stained Aspergillus conidiophore and conidia; Molecular investigation: C) PCR reaction products resolved on 2% Agarose gel, corresponding to bacteria Bacillus (lane B) and Micrococcus (lane Mc) and to fungi Aspergillus (lane A) and Penicillium (lane P). M?=?molecular weight marker, 100 bp DNA ladder.

Antimicrobial activity of BMA₁ and BMA₂ was tested against these microbial taxa, establishing the MIC (Minimal Inhibitory
Concentration) and the MBC/MFC, Minimal Bactericidal/Fungicidal Concentration 18]-20]. Laboratory tests were performed on two different sets of twelve glue paste – canvas
specimens. BMAs or Nipagin-M solutions (final concentration of 1.4 mg/ml) were added
in 2.5 ml of glue paste, followed by its deposition on linen or synthetic canvas.

As shown in Figure 3B, C, D, the addition of BMA₁, or BMA₂ or Nipagin-M (Methylparaben) to glue paste–linen specimens, inhibited fungal growth;
in absence an extended colonization occurred (Figure 3A). Tests on glue paste- synthetic canvas showed an evident Aspergillus niger growth when any BMAs were added (Figure 3E), while a total growth inhibition was in presence of BM₁ (Figure 3F) and a partial antifungal activity was in the presence of BM₂ (Figure 3G) or Nipagin–M (Figure 3H).

Figure 3. Microbial growth inhibition in glue paste-canvas specimens by BMAs. Fungal growth
(Aspergillus niger): absence of antimicrobial molecules in glue-paste linen canvas (A) or glue paste – synthetic canvas (E) specimens. Fungal growth is completely inhibited on linen canvas by BMA₁(B), or BMA₂(C) or Nipagin-M (D) and on synthetic canvas by BM₁(F). A reduced fungal growth is showed in glue paste – synthetic canvas specimens in
presence of BMA₂(G) or Nipagin-M (H) molecules.

We demonstrate that these bioactive molecules can be utilized in cultural heritage
field, by implementing the efficiency of applicative protocols, according to the conservative
restoration procedure. This study focalizes on sustainable restoration alternatives
which are both operator and environment-friendly, reducing costs and operating times.