The 5 Worst ‘Natural’ Ingredients


This article was written by Emily Main and provided by our partners at Rodale News.

If you saw “poison ivy” listed as an ingredient in your favorite salad mix, would you eat it? Probably not. But poison ivy is natural, right? Who cares if it gives you a heinous rash and makes you miserable? The food industry might as well apply the same logic to all the other so-called “natural” ingredients it tries to sneak into processed foods. Ingredients made from seaweed, palm trees, and fruit juice may have a health halo, but they actually come with more risks than benefits—no matter how natural they sound. Here are five you should watch out for.

Caramel Coloring
Behind the label: Caramel candies get their coloring from caramelized sugar, which turns brown as it’s heated. The caramel coloring you find in your soda—not so much. It’s created when sugar is heated with ammonium compounds, and the process creates a cancer-causing byproduct called 4-MI, which exists as a contaminant in caramel food coloring at varying levels. Coca-Cola recently switched to a lower-MI formulation of its caramel coloring, but tests from the Center for Science in the Public Interest recently found sodas sold across the country with widely varying—and dangerous—levels.

Your move: Do you really need that soda? After all, cancer-causing contaminants are just one of many disturbing side effects of soda, which include kidney problems and liver fat. If you do need your bubbly, opt for one of these eight healthy sodas.

Palm Oil
Behind the label: Palm oil became the go-to replacement for partially hydrogenated vegetable oils after the FDA instituted trans fat-labeling rules on processed foods—but that replacement didn’t do much for public health. A number of studies suggest that palm oil is as bad for your heart as the trans fats hidden in partially hydrogenated oils. The most recent—from the USDA—found that it raised bad LDL cholesterol levels as much as partially hydrogenated soybean oil.

In addition to its heart-damaging health problems, enormous tracts of rainforests and peat bogs have been razed or filled in to make room for palm oil plantations. Peat bogs are ecologically valuable because they sequester globe-warming carbon dioxide, and rainforest destruction has led to the endangerment of 140 animal species in Indonesia and another 50 in Malaysia, the world’s two largest producers of palm oil.

Your move: Palm oil is mostly used in crackers, cookies, and other baked goods, so scrutinize labels. Safflower oil and sunflower oil are healthier and don’t carry the problems associated with other genetically modified vegetable oils made from corn, canola, and soy. If your favorite product does contain palm oil, call the manufacturer and ask how it was sourced. Some companies use palm oil produced under an industry group called the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil, which is trying to develop standards that would protect vital species habitats.

Evaporated Cane Juice
Behind the label: Evaporated cane juice may sound benign enough, but it’s essentially refined white sugar with a fancier name, according to naturopathic physician Andrew Weil, M.D. It’s not even really juice but dried crystals that are left behind after raw sugar cane has been boiled. Those crystals then undergo additional processing, removing any vitamins and minerals that may have existed in the raw sugar cane. Because it isn’t juice, the FDA has proposed new rules that would make the term illegal on food packages, opting instead for “sugar” or “dried cane syrup.” The agency has even sent warning letters to juice manufacturers who use the term misleadingly, for instance advertising a product as “100 percent juice.”

Your move: When you do need processed foods, opt for those containing sweeteners with real nutritional value, such as real maple syrup, molasses, raw honey, and others that made our list of the five best sweeteners.

Fruit Juice Concentrate
Behind the label: You probably see the words “fruit juice concentrate” on a jar of jam or in a fruit drink and think it’s got to be healthier than sugar, right? Wrong. Apple, pear, and white grape fruit juice concentrates are some of the most commonly used sweeteners added to foods, and they’re simply empty calories, according to the Harvard School of Public Health. They’re used as fat replacements because their water content provides bulk, yet they still contain high levels of fructose—a form of sugar tied to heart problems and one that can actually lower your ability to remember things.

Your move: Fruit is “nature’s candy,” so eat it whole. The fructose levels are tempered by the added fiber, vitamins, and minerals you get when downing whole fruits. When you do need processed foods, opt for those containing sweeteners with real nutritional value, such as real maple syrup, molasses, and raw honey.

High-Fructose Corn Syrup
Behind the label: There’s little redeeming nutritional value to HFCS—the ubiquitous sweetener added to everything from bread to salad dressing. It provides empty calories, it’s been linked to heart disease, and the manufacturing process has the potential to contaminate it with brain-damaging mercury. Yet HFCS still shows up in so-called “natural” foods. Back in 2008, the FDA decided that, due to the highly industrialized process used to create HFCS, using the sweetener in products labeled “natural” was deceptive and misleading. But after backlash from the Corn Refiners Association, the agency reversed that decision two months later.

Your move: Few nutritionists out there would agree with the Corn Refiners Association’s assertion that HFCS is “natural,” but since they don’t make the rules, it’s up to you to read labels. HFCS is very common in “low-fat” foods, so read ingredient lists.

More from Rodale News:
5 Ways Grains Destroy Your Skin
Is This New Ingredient Triggering Your Allergies?
You’re Eating ‘Extreme’ Levels of This Pesticide